ANNIE
METZLER INSURANCE Agency
As a full service independent insurance agency, our network of insurance companies enables us to provide personalized options that ensure great insurance coverage at exceptional rates. We look forward to getting to know you.
Please note our new phone number: 717-786-6005. Contact an agent today!
Or
email: info@metzlerinsurance.com
Farm Insurance
Whether you need to cover a family farm or a large agricultural operation, we can provide insurance policies designed to meet your needs and limit your liabilities. Let us help you protect your personal property, farm equipment, and farm structures.
Personal Insurance
Let our agents find the best coverage for you, including Home, Auto, and Life Insurance. Sorting through all the insurance coverages available can be a daunting task. While you’re probably familiar with car insurance and homeowner’s insurance policies, what you may not know is how much coverage you really need based on your life circumstances.
Commercial Insurance
Are you looking for a commercial insurance agent that really understands your needs and works to protect your business and your family? We’ll be happy to answer your questions about Commercial Property, Worker’s Compensation, Umbrella policies, and so much more.
Welcome to Annie Metzler Insurance Agency — Offering Farm Insurance, Personal Insurance, Business Insurance, and Commercial Insurance
We are a full service independent agency that takes the time to establish a strong relationship with you while focusing on finding you the best coverage for the lowest price.
We specialize in farm insurance with large competitive selection of farm companies to choose from.
We also offer business, workers compensation, auto, home, life and crop insurance. Do you own a rental property? We insure rental/habitational properties too! We take the time to get to know you and review your policies each year and do offer home/business/farm visits. Excellent claim service is a high priority for our agency. We are licensed and provide insurance in Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Delaware.
Call our office at (717) 786-6005. We look forward to getting to know you.
Annie W. Metzler Insurance — Established 1993
Our 30 Year Heritage
Annie W. Metzler opened the Annie W. Metzler Insurance Agency in 1993 after working for several insurance agencies in the Solanco area. For the first few years, Annie operated the agency at a location on E. State Street in Quarryville, PA.
Annie worked to establish the agency as a friendly, neighborhood agency, where clients received personal service and concrete advice about their insurance coverage. Annie established relationships with a number of insurance providers, always looking for the best coverage options for personal, commercial and farm lines of insurance.
As the business grew, Annie added several employees to the agency and in 2004 moved the agency office to a new location on Beaver Valley Pike, just north of the borough of Quarryville.
In 2006 Annie purchased a building at 175 Oak Bottom Road that has served as the agency’s main office ever since. Renovations were completed in September of 2006 and not long after that, Annie discovered she had cancer. She continued to operate the business until her death in December of 2009.
In 2010, Kevin Kreider, Annie Metzler’s nephew, and Randy Hart, long-time friend and employee, took over the business after Annie’s death and continued to grow the agency. Their philosophy carries on the principles that the agency was founded on, always getting to know clients and finding the best coverage for their needs.
In 2013 Brent Landis joined the agency as an owner/partner. The agency purchased part of the Weaver Insurance Agency in Quarryville, where Brent had worked for 5 years.
On 12/31/2023 Kevin Kreider’s longtime business partner and friend Randy Hart fully retired and the agency split into two separate agencies. One agency owned by Kevin Kreider by the name of Kreider Insurance Associates Inc., that does business as Annie Metzler Insurance and the other owned by Brent Landis by the name of Annie W Metzler Insurance Agency Inc., that does business as Landis Heritage Insurance. As the agency continues to grow and expand, its philosophy carries on the principals that they were founded on; always getting to know clients and finding the best coverage for their needs.
Our Team — We’re here to answer your insurance questions
Kevin Kreider
Owner
Kevin Joined Annie Metzler Insurance in 2006 to work for his aunt, and founder, Annie Metzler. After her passing in 2009, Kevin and long-time family friend, Randy Hart, took over ownership of the agency. Kevin is a graduate of Lancaster Mennonite School. Kevin is married to Courtney and has two beautiful daughters. When not at work Kevin enjoys spending time with his family and being outdoors.
Krissa Crump
Customer Service Representative
Krissa began working as a customer service representative at Annie Metzler Insurance in 2017. Previous to insurance, Krissa worked in banking. She is a graduate of Solanco High School and Millersville University with a BA in History. Krissa is married to Jerry and they have 2 daughters, Cierra and Maven, and 1 son, Westly. Krissa is an active member of Chestnut Level Presbyterian Church. When Krissa isn’t spending time with her family, she enjoys outdoor activities and reading.
Kylie Risser
Customer Service Representative
Kylie began working at Annie Metzler Insurance in 2023 as a customer service representative. Prior to working at the agency, Kylie had worked on the family farm, Kreider Mulch Farms, and was a PCA for an in-home nursing agency. She is a graduate from Penn Manor High School and was involved in FFA. Kylie is married to Zac, owner of Risser Lawncare, and they attend Community Bible Church together. Kylie enjoys riding motorcycle, hunting, snowmobiling, boating, and traveling with her husband.
Leann Burgos
Customer Service Representative
Leann is the daughter of (former) partner Randy Hart and began working for the agency in 2012. She is married to Andrew and they have two children, Leilani and Liam. She took some time away from the agency to focus on her family but is excited to be working again with Kevin. Leann is a graduate of Solanco High School and Millersville University. She pursues many interests, including a love of the theatre.
Randy Hart
Retired Partner
Randy joined Annie Metzler Insurance in 1999. Kevin and Randy knew each other for a number of years before Randy joined the agency. Randy is a graduate of Solanco High School and Millersville University. After Annie’s death in 2009, Randy and Kevin took over ownership of the agency. Randy is married to Debbie, who taught elementary art in the Solanco School District. They have three children; Leann, Marla, and Marcus. Randy enjoys spending time with his family and coaching his Challenger Little League team.
Randy partially retired on March 31, 2023 and fully retired on 12/31/2023. During Randy’s 25 years at the agency, his reputation for great customer service has everyone’s best interest in mind. Randy was truly a great business partner and mentor —he is still available for those tough insurance questions we need a quick answer to.
Refer a Friend — It's Easy!
Receive a gift card when you refer a friend and we write their insurance!
It’s easy and simple! Have your friend mention your name at Metzler Insurance and when we write their insurance you receive a gift card!
Annie Metzler Insurance Agency
Physical Address:
175 Oak Bottom Road, Quarryville, PA 17566
Mailing Address:
P.O. Box 322, Quarryville, PA 17566
Phone: 717-786-6005
Fax: 717-786-6004
Email: info@metzlerinsurance.com
Copyright © 2024. All Rights Reserved. Annie Metzler Insurance Agency.
Annie Metzler Insurance values your privacy and is committed to protecting your personal information. We understand the importance of safeguarding the data you provide to us and maintaining your trust.
